Independence 211
![]() Vol: 21 , No.211, January 2004 |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||
Message Dear Reader: This is the time when people are busy drawing up lists of friends and sending them cards and presents. For myself and my colleagues, we have so many friends it has taken us a lot of time to prepare our New Year present for you all. By the time it's ready, the New Year will already be in the past. All the same, we hope you are satisfied with our work, and that our 'horrendous crime' of not having reciprocated your good will and friendship will be forgiven. Mysoong! (Wishing You Progress & Prosperity) S.H.A.N. |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
SHAN Diary 2003 |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||
The World
19 March
International Relations
7 October
Thai-Burma Relations
15 July
15 December Politics
30 August
5 September
22 November Shans
1 July
13-15 October Economy / Business
10 February
24 April
21 June
12 November
15 November
23 November Human Rights
22 September
12 November
20 November
28 November
9 December Environment
2 November |
1 December
16 December Drugs
13 January
1 February
26 June
20 July
24 July
5 December War
July
21 July
5 August
16 October
20 October
10 November
13 November Bereavement
7 March
2 June
7 December |
||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||
Quotes
Today in Burma, if you have more money than your opponent, you will win the case. 99 out of 100 people know it.
Insisting on curing and looking after the victims without removing the perpetrators could be like putting the cart in front of the horse.
Confidence building is like testing the water before swimming. But if you spend too much time testing the water, it might be interpreted that you don't want to swim.
If a people was denied the right to self determination, it is colonialism.
We are not a brutal people. We have loving kindness for everybody. We are not a heartless people.
Burma has no problem to find, beat and imprison political opponents, so claims ring hollow that drug traffickers are difficult to find.
Blaming Burma's present troubles to colonial legacy has been too much overworked, says a Burmese scholar, Dr. U Myint, because Burma is not the only country in Asia to have been colonized by the British.
Only a roadmap that arises from the Tripartite Dialogue can be genuine.
No political transition in the world worked without the basic political freedoms.
How can we build a modern country when our slogan is Oppose, Oppose, Oppose and Crush? |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Shan State in 2003 |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||
Over the world, the big headlines were the US-UK attack and subsequent occupation of Iraq and SARS. In Burma, headlines were made by the bank crisis, the Dipeyin massacre followed by the re-arrest of Aung San Suu Kyi, President Bush's signing of new Burma sanctions, Gen Khin Nyunt's appointment as prime minister and his roadmap initiative which, according to some analysts, has become the only game in town to play. The People
Are the generals ready for democracy? But these positive developments were overwhelmingly drowned out by continued negative reports from each and every corner of Burma that various news agencies, unrecognized by the generals, could reach. Extra-judicial killings continued: on 29 March, two monks at Htam Loikong, Kunhing township, were shot to death by Captain Than Naing Oo from Infantry Battalion 246. Another shooting of 11 farmers that resulted in 4 killed and 4 injured, took place at Nawngpan in the same township on 29 April. Sources confirmed, despite junta accusations, that it was not the Shan resistance but the Army that had committed the crimes. IB 246, together with Light Infantry Battalion 524, were charged by Shan State Army "North", a ceasefire group, in 2000 of massacring 85 villagers in 2 consecutive incidents.
Their threats were not idle. Two village committee members who had testified to the Red Cross on 30 January were later flogged until both of them were covered with blood from head to toe. Another 3 villagers who were interviewed by whom they thought were Red Cross officials on 1 June were taken away from their homes two days later by "Shan rebels who spoke fluent Burmese but pidgin Shan" never to be seen again. Their mysterious disappearance generated so much terror among the locals, many of them decided to leave their homes and flee to Thailand. Apparently irked by negative results, the ICRC's later visits concentrated more on health and sanitation issues and less on the human rights situation. The visitors also filed complaints with authorities about the unusual presence of Burmese patrols during their tours. By the end of the year, it was also expanding its field operation to Namzarng, Kunhing and Mongnai townships.
However, after the new policy came into force later in the year, it was discovered by the farmers that rice traders who had been assigned by the government to purchase paddy from them could sell only at 1,500 kyat per basket to the government, a situation totally unexpected by all. ("I knew there was a catch somewhere in [the policy]," grumbled a Shan trader from Kengtung.) This resulted in the traders stalling for time until the cash-strapped farmers would inevitably be forced to reduce their prices.
Recognized IDPs and Refugees along Thai-Burma border 9 July 31 December
Environment The Salween Dam Following an agreement signed between Thailand's MDX Group and Burma's Ministry of Electric Power on 20 December 2002, work on the Tasarng Dam on the Salween was expected to begin earnestly. However, most of the news published during the year spoke very little about Tasarng, but only about Weigyi, between Karen State and the kingdom downstream instead, although nothing concrete was made known by the end of the year. Upstream, a 22-men team of Thai experts reportedly arrived in Tasarng on 21 January. Salween Watch, a group formed in 1998, said for a month the group was engaged in digging 4 tunnels, 2 on each side of the river at the dam site, and drilling perpendicular holes that reached the water level. During the period, 30 of the hired workers from lowland Burma were said to have perished due to the cave-ins and other causes. Apart from this, the experts were seen taking measurements of the water depth each morning and evening. Meanwhile a new road, 25 ft wide, 12-15 km long, was being built by Thai Sawad, a Burma-based Thai company. Since then, nothing much appeared to be happening, except for the ongoing road-repair at the site of what is to become, upon its completion, the biggest megadam in Southeast Asia. BP-1, the border checkpoint, where most of the construction materials from Thailand should go through when the project becomes full swing, is still closed, although a few trucks have been allowed to cross since 12 December. It seems the parties concerned have decided that transparency is the last thing they want at least for the time being. The Mekong reef blasting Activists both from Burma and Thailand lodged a joint petition to China on 12 December 2002 to halt the second batch of blasting of 16 rapids located between Burma's Shan State and Laos during the period 15 December 2002-15 March 2003. It had already caught the local people unaware by its blasting of two rapids earlier. To no one's surprise, the request simply fell on deaf ears and the blasting went on. One disastrous result was the drowning of 7 Lahu villagers from Palio-Kenglarb (in Tachilek township) whose boat was overturned on 31 December 2002 by the wake of a convoy of at least 5 large Chinese cargo boats traveling downstream. The Mekong Navigation Improvement Project, led by China, aims to make the region's longest river navigable for vessels of 500 tons. For some reason, the plan to blast the remaining batch of reefs, December 2003-March 2004, was not implemented and a new EIA (Environmental Impact Assessment) is being conducted, according to Chiangmai-based Southeast Asia Rivers Network (SEARIN). This may prove a breather for the local people but certainly not a victory. The Kengtawng hydropower project Undaunted by the failure of Chinese engineers to build a dam at Kengtawng's 795 ft high falls, the Ministry of Electric Power again engaged Japan to send a team of experts to visit the location and figure out a way to harness the raging waters. By 5 December 2002, Col Tint Lwin, the area commander was able to inform the local populace that within 2 years the falls would be able to supply electricity not only to Kengtawng but also the whole southern Shan State. By May, S.H.A.N. was told by a former headman from Kengtawng that the only thing remaining was to wait for the arrival of generators from Japan. Rangoon's optimism was also confirmed by The New Light of Myanmar, 1 August, that contained a map showing the planned power supply system upon completion. The security cordon had also been tight, by all accounts, all of which seemed to indicate that the activities on the Salween dam site might well turn out to be a mere diversion. War Throughout the year, the Shan State Army of Col Yawdserk has unusually been "behaving itself." At the beginning of the year, on 11 January, it announced a unilateral ceasefire along the border: that it would not fight unless attacked. Towards the end of the year, another declaration was issued that it was ready to talk to Rangoon if the latter wished so, without conditions. This was a far cry from the three previous consecutive years, 2000-2002, when clashes between the Shan and junta armies along the unsettled boundary had almost brought the two countries to the brink of open war. To be sure, random clashes still continued. The Burma Army, still smarting from a pyrrhic victory in 2002, when it had suffered an estimated 800-1,000 casualties, spent the whole year rebuilding its manpower, roads and fortifications. The SSA even launched a military campaign which is still ongoing in Tachilek and Monghpyak townships, opposite Chiangrai, in November. But nothing hit the headlines except Thai efforts to "establish order" along the border and mediate between the two sides. One result was the removal of one Shan base across Chiangmai's Chiangdao district in October and, the other, the downgrading of drug-related liaison between the SSA and the Thai Army. The Thai mediation, on the other hand, did not appear to move Rangoon much, when it came to opening talks with the SSA. On 10 March, Maj Gen Kyaw Win, Gen Khin Nyunt's deputy, reconfirmed that the SSA had no choice but to surrender. However, some Thai officials are counting on Rangoon to reconsider its stance, after agreement is hopefully reached between it and the Karen National Union, the SSA's ally, in January. The year also witnessed mysterious explosions in Tachilek, on 21 May, coincidently the 45th anniversary of the Shan resistance, which killed 4 and damaged the statue of King Bayintnaung, who conquered the Shans in 1555 and Ayuddhya in 1569. Suspicion naturally fell on the SSA, whose leader firmly denied involvement. Other observers, reportedly including Wei Hsuehkang, meanwhile believed it must be the handiwork of the Burmese military itself. In any case, bilateral relations, for the first time, were unaffected by the incident. |
It is therefore difficult to say what the prospects are with regards to the military situation in Shan State. However, one thing may be clear. No future military operations in eastern Shan State will be launched either by the Shans or Rangoon without taking into careful consideration the presence of China's 13th Army, reportedly a Level A field unit, meaning equipped with sophisticated weaponry, that took over border security from the paramilitary police Wujin in July. Politics Admirers do not hesitate to assert that among today's Shan leaders, Khun Toon Oo, with no army to command and no international standing worth talking about, outshines others for his courage. On 6 January, he was informed by the military authorities that the 8-party United Nationalities Alliance (UNA), formed on 31 July 2002 in order to "prepare for the eventual tripartite dialogue" and which had appointed him as spokesperson, would not be recognized. That however has not stopped him from continuing his activities on its behalf. On 7 February, Sao Nood a.k.a Sai Nyunt Lwin, 52, Acting General Secretary of the Shan Nationalities League for Democracy, was arrested. The arrest took place while Amnesty International was on its historic first visit in Burma. Undaunted, Khun Toon Oo held a meeting with the Shan State Army "North" and Shan State National Army, member groups of the Joint Action Committee founded by him, and sent a petition to the military council. Three months later, on 20 May, Sai Nood was freed. He was reportedly "incensed", when generals Hsoten and Loimao, had an audience with PM Khin Nyunt on 22 November, without meeting him first. The matter however was quiclkly resolved and by early January, the JAC was able to report that its members would continue to work together "sharing heat and cold alike." With Aung San Suu Kyi and her top leaders still incarcerated, Khun Toon Oo has accidentally become a figure much sought out both by foreign dignitaries on visits and the media. What he says has also been given more attention now than ever. Throughout the year, he has staunchly stood by the UNA's principle: dialogue must come before the "National Convention". Chao Tzang Yawnghwe, one of his admirers, commented that his stand "is good, firm, principled and conciliatory, avoids threats and is not threatening to the generals who are already frightened and desperate." For the Shan exiles, it was another busy year. Among the groups, rights campaigning trips by Shan Women's Action Network (SWAN) and political lobbying trips by the Shan Democratic Union, have been the most prominent. The SDU, together with the Karen National Union, during their visits to Greece, Portugal, Spain and the Netherlands, had, likening Burma to a house under siege and its military as the perpetrators, emphasized that "insisting to cure and look after the victims without removing the perpetrators would be like putting the cart in front of the horse". All in all, they were satisfied with the outcome of their trips, according to Wansai, SDU General Secretary, because of assurance given by EU member countries of their determination to continue pushing for Tripartite Dialogue. (One of EU's concern was that the non-Burmans would opt for secession as the way out. To this the representatives had assured that there would not be any boat rocking.) The year also saw the Shan State Army of Col Yawdserk, long regarded as a drawback to National Reconciliation because of its Total Independence stand, making a conciliatory move by declaring on 12 August a "popular resolution" to support an 8-state union structure. The upshot, according to Chao Tzang Yawnghwe, Shan State's foremost scholar and activist, was open praise by an official working with the UN, who had met Shan groups both in Burma and abroad, that Shans were the most united. "We have different groups like different parts of a vehicle, but they work well together," he told a Shan Exchange meeting on 9 July. "What he said is in line with 'Unity in Diversity' and 'Common Goal, Diverse action' principles that we have been espousing. Of course, it is not dictatorial unity (one blood, one voice, one command) as some uninformed people are taught to believe, but a democratic unity". How strong this "democratic unity" will prove in the face of Rangoon's roadmap initiative and the National Convention to be held in 2004 is anybody's guess. But few would deny it will be fatal just to take it for granted. Drugs Outwardly, drug control in Burma was a promising prospect.
Thai-Burma relations In January, Phu Jad Karn "The Manager", reported on the Thaksin administration's Burma strategy, the cardinal aim being "changing enemies into friends". The plan included: To support peace building in the region and To play a leading role in resolving border problems, such as providing suitable livelihoods for people living on both sides of the border. On the business front, it would stop asking for concessions. Instead, "we shall propose a joint venture where the profits shall be shared fifty-fifty between us," said Gen Pat Akkaniyabutr, President of the Thai-Myanmar Cultural and Economic Assicoation, that was founded in 2001. Upon his return from a 2-day visit to Rangoon on 10 February, Thaksin said Rangoon had agreed to let him help rebels negotiate with the country's military rulers. A plan was then reportedly drafted which recognized that conflict resolution by Rangoon and the non-Burman armed movements would be in the interest of Thailand and accordingly opted for a proactive policy. It proposed that dialogue between the two sides should be conducted simultaneously with that between Rangoon and Aung San Suu Kyi. It also said preventing the opposition from using Thai territory to create violence in Burma did not mean "preventing them from using the territory to work for national reconciliation. "The plan also moved to develop the ethnic areas along the border following achievement of reconciliation. At the same time, it also specifically stated that "Thailand shall not resort to pressure to bring about a structural change. We must determine practical and achievable goals, making sure that they are not at variance with the SPDC " However, the plan was abruptly interrupted by the 30 May massacre in northern Burma followed by Aung San Suu Kyi's custody. But Thaksin was not one to allow the situation to return to normal for long. On his next visit to Burma, 10-12 November, he again urged his counterpart Khin Nyunt to include ethnic groups along the Thai border to be part of the talks on his roadmap, announced on 30 August. (The visit, highlighted by the Pagan declaration that put on paper Thaksin's concept: 4 countries, 1 economy, had prompted one prominent Shan to dub him as "the uncrowned king of 4 countries" i.e. Burma, Cambodia, Laos and Thailand.) The result was the visit by Col San Pwint, Khin Nyunt's trusted deputy to the Karen National Union in November and a call for another group, Karenni National Progress Party, to resume talks. The Shan State Army, however, so far has not been mentioned, although it had agreed to hold talks without pre-conditions. All in all, the year 2004 is likely to continue to keep all those who only wish for peace and security for the long-suffering people on their toes. For those who believe in astrology, the Year of the Monkey has already promised a rough year ahead. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||
Report card
2003
| 2003 | 2002 | |
| Independence newsletter | 8 issues | 8 issues |
|
Salween Post (with Salween News Network) |
7 issues | 4 issues |
| News in English online | 216 pieces | 197 pieces |
| News in Thai online | 531 pieces | 281 pieces |
| Website | 1,967 visits/month | 1,133 visits/month |
|
|
||
|
New entries include: |
||
|
Charting the Exodus from Shan State, |
April 2003 | |
|
Shan Refugees: Dispelling the myths, |
September 2003 | |
|
Aftershocks along Burma's Mekong, |
September 2003 | |
|
Show Business: Rangoon's War on Drugs in Shan State, |
December 2003 | |
|
|
||
| Latest feature Cartoons, by Harnlied that have delighted most readers | ||





















